sharklasers wrote:Hey guys, I'm curious... I've read in a few places that it would be OK to eat a Pinkie from the Yarra/Marbynong river, but not advisable for bream and salmon?
Is there a reason as to why Pinkie's are an exception?
A legal size Bream in over 20 years old. A legal size Pinkie is a couple years old if not less. Bream and Pinkies related so they grow quick initially, like Bream to 20cm and Pinkies to 40cm etc. Then after that they grow very very slowly. So a legal Bream is old, and legal Pinkie is not. Pinkies live out in the Bay and come in for a feed. Black Bream spend most of their life in the Estuary, and are more likely to move up the rivers than into the bay, except for the ones who live there under the major piers etc. So when you see the condition of our city Rivers, that is what turns people off.
When you open a Docklands Bream, its had crushed mussels (water filters). When you open the Pinkie, it has Bait fish.
Eat the Salmon, they are Clean, young fish, fast growers, but taste no good in my opinion.